The 1961 vienna convention on diplomatic relations vcdr, signed in vienna on 18 april 1961, entered into force on 24 april 1964 and the 1963 vienna convention on consular relations vccr, signed in vienna on 24 april 1963, entered into force 19 march 1967 form the core of international diplomatic and consular law. International refugee law specifically provides for the protection of refugees against removal to a country where they would be at risk of persecution. It argues that the law on diplomatic protection has played an important role in setting some benchmarks for the protection of individuals and that the most important element has not only been the international minimum standard itself but the acceptance that this standard. Instead it describes the salient features of diplomatic protection in the sense in which the term is used in the present draft articles.
International law anders henriksen oxford university press. Public international law is traditionally defined as the law between sovereign nationstates, hereinafter, states, especially within the context of the laws of war, peace and security, and protection of territories. Diplomatic protection and international investment. Diplomatic protection and the international court of justice. Diplomatic immunity, in international law, the immunities enjoyed by foreign states or international organizations and their official representatives from the jurisdiction of the country in which they are present. Diplomatic immunity for international organization representatives and personnel. A diplomats handbook of international law and practice. However, the law on diplomatic protection and its development also reflect the structural change of international law itself, and how it has moved from a legal order strictly based on statetostate relations, in which the holder of the right at issue is the state, towards a legal order that lays more emphasis on the protection of the individual. Access to justice, denial of justice and international.
Diplomatic protection in international law and the united nations. Turning to diplomatic protection, he said many of the aspects of international law relating to that topic had taken shape with the spread of reformative ideas originating from the west. The vienna conventions on diplomatic and consular relations. Diplomatic protection is primarily exercised by states towards their nationals, and exceptionally nonnationals, against violations of international law by other states, and is one of the oldest. Diplomatic protection and the lagrand case leiden journal. If the national is a company its nationality must be established. In precise language, diplomatic protection can be defined as a procedure for giving effect to state.
Diplomatic protection as a source of human rights law. Such protection extends to both natural and legal persons. Pdf nationality and diplomatic protection researchgate. Protection, safety and security of diplomatic missions and. Interestingly, international law is often less important than national laws when it comes to defining the immunity of representatives and personnel of international organizations such as the united nations or the international monetary fund. Nov, 2017 thats because diplomatic protection is a mechanism under international law that a state can use to help one of its nationals whose rights have been breached in another country. It is an elementary principle of international law that a state is. Unhcr note on diplomatic assurances and international. Protection against refoulement under international refugee law 7. While the most important feature of the judgment given by the international court of justice in the lagrand case is probably the conclusion that provisional measures indicated by the court are binding, the decision is not without significance in the field of diplomatic protection. The discussions at both workshops were extremely insightful and helpful in directing us towards some of the key issues and ques tions in big data diplomacy. This point was made by the ilc in article 16 on diplomatic protection, according to which rights of natural or legal persons to resort under international law to actions or procedures other than diplomatic protection to secure redress for injury suffered as a result of an internationally wrongful act, are not affected by the present draft. Diplomatic protection is the procedure employed by the state of nationality of the injured person to secure protection of that person, and to obtain reparation for the internationally wrongful act inflicted.
Text adopted by the international law commission at its fiftyeighth session, in 2006, and submitted to the general assembly as a part of the commissions. Already in 1928, in its advisory opinion on jurisdiction of the courts of danzig, the permanent court of international justice pcij recognized that the individual can become a subject of international law and that individuals can benefit from a legal. This book offers an uptodate juristic exposition and analysis of diplomatic protection as an institution of public international law. Diplomatic protection conducted by a state at the interstate level remains an important. For diplomatic protection to be exercised, the injury suffered must be the result of a breach of international law by the host state. Famous cases involving the breaking of diplomatic laws includes the iran hostage crisis i. As is well known, and clearly stated in the commentary to the articles adopted on second reading, diplomatic protection is premised on a fiction. Reassessing the traditional doctrine of diplomatic protection. As diplomatic protection is part of the law of state responsibility. Diplomatic law is that area of international law that governs permanent and temporary diplomatic missions. So, in its historical evolution, access to justice is inseparable from the minimum standard of treatment of aliens. Diplomatic protection is a function of the sovereignty of states under international law within the framework of their mutual rights and obligations in the international community. Dugard, john diplomatic protection and human rights.
These articles largely codify existing customary international law. A fundamental concept of diplomatic law is that of diplomatic immunity, which derives from state immunity. The functions of a diplomatic mission consist, inter alia, in. International court of justice, diplomatic protection, international investment arbitration, investorstate arbitration, customary international law, international investment law, indirect expropriation. Diplomatic protection international law oxford bibliographies.
Diplomatic protection is primarily exercised by states towards their nationals, and exceptionally nonnationals, against violations of international law by other states, and is one of the oldest traditions of international law. International law provides a fresh, studentfocused approach and european perspective on the central issues in public international law. Examples include the denial of justice, imprisonment without trial, discriminatory or arbitrary expropriation, nationalisation or confiscation without compensation. The protection of individual persons in traditional international law diplomatic and consular protection. Due to international events, the doctrine of diplomatic protection has been a subject of. In practice, switzerland provides mostly consular protection as the conditions for extending diplomatic protection are stricter.
These articles largely codify existing customary international law on the protection of nationals abroad by means of diplomatic protection. Diplomatic protection, which has been confirmed in different cases of the permanent court of international justice and the international court of justice, is a discretionary right of a state and may take any form that is not prohibited by international law. Customary international law rule granting states the right to exercise diplomatic protection of their nationals abroad is a good. In its report on the subject in 2006, the international law commission ilc proposed a convention on diplomatic protection which would attempt to resolve the dislocation between the traditional understanding of diplomatic protection as a discretionary right of the state and contemporary human rights vested in individuals. The draft articles of the international law commission 2005 auyrbkintlaw 6. Where one state renders to a second country an individual who is a national of a third nation, international law permits that third country to intervene, seeking relief for the rendered person. Public international law comprehensive course notes. Providing ideal coverage for short foundational courses, this engaging textbook introduces all the essential topics in a concise and manageable way. Nationality and diplomatic protection volume 20 issue 3 guy i. By virtue of the vienna convention on diplomatic relations, the vienna convention on consular relations, the foreign affairs act and other relevant rules and regulations, and according to international customary practice, the diplomatic protocol provides support to the operation of the diplomatic and consular corps and diplomatic missions, international organisations and their missions, and. Draft articles on diplomatic protection, with commentaries, 2006.
Shareholder protection in international investment law. Diplomatic protection is the procedure employed by the state of. The investor must have exhausted all local remedies in the host country. It denotes the process by which a state asserts a claim against another state because one of its nationals has been treated by the latter in violation of international law. Table of contents overview of international law il 9. Report on the work of the international law commission during its 48th. Brody for their assistance in preparing this chapter. Relevant caselaw supporting the idea behind diplomatic protection, the pcij held in the mavrommatis palestine concessions case jurisdiction greece v uk that. An examination of the area of diplomatic protection in conjunction with rights of peaceful protest and of the relevant legal issues, requires attention to be paid to certain basic criteria.
Big data for foreign policy, took place in october in helsinki. Diplomatic protection becomes more difficult, however, where the ren. This book offers a juristic exposition and analysis of diplomatic protection as an institution of public international law. It argues that the law on diplomatic protection has played an important role in setting some benchmarks for the protection of individuals and that the most important element has not only been the international minimum standard itself but the acceptance that this standard prevailed over national law by the mid1920s. These include, in particular, the special duties vested in australia, as the receiving state, by international. Nationality and diplomatic protection international. But diplomatic protection has several disadvantages. Diplomatic protection diplomatic protection is where the home state intervenes on behalf of its nationals who suffer a violation of international law by the host state.
The inviolability of diplomatic envoys has been recognized by most civilizations and. A head of mission or any member of the diplomatic staff of the mission may act as representative of the sending state to any international organization. Statement on diplomatic protection, international liability. International law permits a state to choose in the context of diplomatic protection which corporate bodies it regards as its nationals, and there is. It then discusses the development of the law of diplomatic protection by the icj by reference to four general topics. Diplomatic protection is one of the traditional concepts of classical international law that has developed over the centuries. Key elements of diplomatic law are the immunity of diplomatic staff, the inviolability of the diplomatic mission and its grounds, and the security of diplomatic correspondence and diplomatic bags. The institution of diplomatic protection is a substantive as well as a procedural device in international law. Leigh due to essential maintenance, article purchase will be unavailable until 12.
Diplomatic immunity legal definition of diplomatic immunity. In may 2006 the ilc adopted on second reading its draft articles on diplomatic protection. Thats because diplomatic protection is a mechanism under international law that a state can use to help one of its nationals whose rights have been breached in another country. A state exercising diplomatic protection espouses the claim of its national and pursues it in its own name on the international plane. Government publishing office page 277 taiwan allies international protection and enhancement initiative taipei act of 2019 page 4 stat. It can include consular action, negotiations with the other state, political and. Chapter two the institution of diplomatic protection 1. In theory, the sources of international environmental law are the same as those of general international law. A principle of international law that provides foreign diplomats with protection from legal action in the country in which they work established in large part by the vienna conventions, diplomatic immunity is granted to individuals depending on their rank and the amount of immunity they need to carry out their duties without legal harassment. Diplomatic protection and the international court of. Nationality and diplomatic protection springerlink. While these concerns of international law remain paramount among states today, the. The individual has rights under international law but remedies are few.
1372 309 1430 263 379 1462 1536 1195 398 201 154 465 921 1198 956 1164 615 174 752 132 1244 737 793 1062 1506 333 314 1447 1520 449 210 1193 708 59 1021 701 1317 1034 49 194 683 1061 458 1058 1344 521